Skip To Content


    My husband and I recently had the pleasure to work with Craig and Amy for the listing and sell of our home. Prior to listing our home, we interviewed three potential realtors to work with. There was just something in our gut that told us to work with Craig and Amy within a matter of seconds of meeting them. And boy, their job performance did not disappoint! Now we mostly worked with Amy but Craig was there if we needed anything. Both individuals are personable, creative, and fun to work with. Amy things of every detail to make your listing top notch. They have professional photographers, cleaning services, and professional staging services. We were in contract within 24 hours and they made sure everything went through smoothly to make sure the closing is completed. We did not have the experience of working with Craig and Amy through purchasing a home but I cannot imagine the experience being any different. We highly recommend Craig and Amy Balster as your next realtor.

    Josh & Stephanie

    Craig and Amy are amazing and made my whole selling process flawless and easy. They worked with me on a realistic timeline and check list of things to do to prepare my home for sale. They are so knowledgeable about what buyers are looking for and they did a great job helping to stage my home. It was priced right from the beginning and ready for showings from day one. I had multiple offers right away. Communication was very easy and all of my questions we answered quickly. I was provided status updates throughout the entire process so I was always in the loop.  Choosing Craig & Amy to be your realtors is an easy decision and you will want to thank me for it!


    Without a shadow of a doubt we would recommend Craig and Amy. The home sales cycle is an emotional rollercoaster. Craig and Amy balance one another perfectly presenting a level of calm, professionalism and support in the midst of the storm. This team knows the Westerville market inside and out and steers the home selling process with a steady arm and poised acumen. They partnered with us, helping us to meet the needs for a successful home sale. Day 1 ended with 3 offers. That’s winning!

    Ron & Myra

    As a first time home buyer, I was very anxious about the process. However, Amy made the experience very easy and enjoyable. With Amy’s persistence and knowledge of the area, I was able to find my very first home and couldn’t be happier!


    My experience with Amy and Craig was fantastic. They were always prepared, very knowledgeable, and so kind and thoughtful. They sold our house quickly and made it as easy and painless as possible. Thanks, Amy and Craig!


    I was relocating to the area from across the country and needed someone who is responsive, knowledgeable and professional. Amy proved to be all of those qualities and more. She listened and was responsive to my ideas and also provided some wonderful options. In fact, the home I purchased was one that she identified based on her knowledge of the area and my description of the home that I wanted. We walked into the home and I loved it. Amy’s knowledge and expertise extends also to her relationship with other professionals. She made the process of purchasing a home enjoyable.


    It was seamless. Craig did a great job getting our house out there and it sold in 1 month! We could not be happier!

    Tom & Mary

    Greg and I want to thank your for all you’ve done to find us a new home and sell ours. You have been wonderful to work with and its been a pleasure getting to know you. While finding a home proved to be much more difficult and heartbreaking than we anticipated, your patience and dedication in helping us, got us through. Without your help we couldn’t have found our perfect home. We also appreciate the hard work you put into selling our house. The whole process has gone so well, after hearing what some people have been through, we feel spoiled! You just made it too easy!

    Greg & Amy

    Just a quick note to thank you for all your time and effort to help us make our choice. We could not have done it without you! Can’t wait to met your family and have you over for a barbeque!

    Richard, Karrie & Kaylee

    Craig helped us find our home in August. Relocating from out of state, we only had a week! Craig listened so well he was able to adjust our search quickly making the most of our limited time. He also made sure the inspection and closing process went smoothly even though we were thousands of miles away. I highly recommend Craig.

    Scott & Ann

    Contact Us Now

    Any questions, comments, or feedback